22. E.T. vs Super 8

We’re pitting one of film history’s all-time classics—the Stephen Spielberg masterpiece, E.T.—against the J.J. Abram's 2001 film clearly inspired by it, Super 8.  

Featuring: Garrett Holmes, Josh Porter, Josiah DePaoli, Matt Hughes, Mike Jensen, Patrick Porter, Peter Nikiforov, and Tyler Hanns.

Major Spoilers: E.T. and Super 8.

Minor & Abstract Spoilers: Psycho, Interstellar, Mac & Me, Peanuts, 2001: A Space Odyssey, The Muppet Movie, Mad Max: Fury Road, Wall-E, Star Wars Episode I, Independence Day, Austin Powers, Cloverfield, White Fang, Harry and the Hendersons, The Iron Giant, Goonies, Indiana Jones, and Thomas the Tank Engine (again).

Feel like we’re overlooking a quality argument? Leave a comment.